Discussion » There's so much comedy on TV. Does that cause comedy in the streets?

This is a read-only copy. The forum ran on iamcal.com from 2000 until its database was lost in 2016, and this topic was rebuilt from copies saved by the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine. Some replies may be missing, and its dates are approximate.
Posted by Saltation_DUPE1, around October 2005:
 
DOOM et al have made the streets safer! presumably because all the nutters now stay inside where it's easier to kill things.

Posted by Saltation_DUPE1, around 23rd October 2005:
 
oh superb:
When a convicted murderer says his crime was caused by something that, if true, would absolve him of responsibility, you must hold out the possibility that he might not be telling the truth.

Or, just run the numbers. GTA III sold seven million copies worldwide. Let's conservatively say that another million were pirated. So we have this case and then I know of another in Japan where the game was cited as the cause. That means one in four million users suffered from murderous impulses after playing it. That's .00003%.

Can any manufacturer be held liable with those kinds of numbers, even if it could somehow be pinpointed as the exclusive reason for the crime? For comparison, one industry study predicted that one hundred times that many gamers will wind up getting the new Revolution controller stuck up their ass.